265 High oil consumption on one cylinder - mk3 265

So a few months ago my timing belt snapped. I had the engine fixed. We put in new valves, valve stem seals, camshaft oil seals, camshaft pulleys, new belt kit and sealed the engine head. We also fitted new spark plugs and injectors.

I had the car back for a few days, did about 300km and noticed that my engine drinks a lot of oil. I had to top it up twice, with a total of 1.5L, which is about half a liter per 100km.

We took out the spark plugs and noticed that the spark plug on cylinder 4 was running hot, it was somwhat burned. The spark plugs were also new. When i took a look inside the cylinder, i noticed that cylinder 4 was very wet with oil.

Of course my first concern was that its the pistong rings, but the compression test was fine. I had 8.5-9bar of compression on all cylinders. Car was luke warm (not cold, not fully warmed up).

When i had my engine apart we inspected the pistons and none of them had any visible damage and scorching on the walls was also good.

I already tried replacing one of the PCVs but it didnt help - I also think that it can't be the PCV because i have oil in only one cylinder.

What could be the issue here?

*Im attaching pictures of the pistions (when we were fixing the snapped timing belt), the spark plugs (cylinder 1 on far left, cylinder 4 on far right) and the compression test (bottom 4 readings).